Churches in Shelter Island, NY
3 church congregations listed in Shelter Island, New York, compiled from public map data. Call ahead or check the website for service times, and see our visiting guide if you are church hunting.
Shelter Island Presbyterian
32 N Ferry Rd · Shelter Island, NY 11964
Our Lady of the Isle Church
5 Prospect Ave · Shelter Island, NY 11965 · Catholic
Union Chapel in the Grove
19 Wesley Ave · Shelter Island, NY 11965
New to the area, or new to church?
Denominational labels on these listings come from public data and can be imperfect. Our plain-language guide explains what the labels mean before you visit.
Understand the denominations